Job Favoritism Sexual Harassment in California

Where You Need a Lawyer:

(This may not be the same place you live)

At No Cost! 

 What Is Considered Sexual Harassment in the Workplace in California?

Sexual harassment in the workplace is a grave issue that can have severe consequences for the victims as well as for employers. California defines sexual harassment as unwanted sexual advances or visual, verbal, or physical conduct of a sexual nature. This definition is not limited to overtly sexual behavior but can also include derogatory comments, slurs, or other offensive actions based on one’s gender.

Avoiding sexual harassment is crucial, not only for a harmonious workplace but also to adhere to state and federal laws. The EEOC (Equal Employment Opportunity Commission) further lays out guidelines on what may be deemed as harassment, helping employees and employers identify and prevent such actions.

Is Sexual Favoritism Illegal in the Workplace?

Pervasive sexual favoritism at work can create a hostile work environment, violating anti-discrimination laws. Sometimes, employees are granted promotions, benefits, or other job perks primarily based on their participation in a romantic or sexual relationship with someone in authority (like a manager or supervisor). This can be seen as discriminatory against those who don’t engage in such relationships.

Recent legal developments in California have shed light on the intricacies of workplace relationships and how they intersect with sexual harassment laws. A noteworthy court case, Miller v. Department of Corrections, has adjusted the lens through which California views office affairs, particularly when those affairs result in alleged favoritism. In this landmark case, the court recognized a sexual harassment claim raised by two female workers, asserting that their manager’s preferential treatment towards his romantic partners was discriminatory.

What Was the Situation Involved in This Case?

At the heart of this case were former female staff members of the Valley State Prison for Women in Chowchilla. Their grievance was aimed squarely at the institution’s warden.

Rumors and allegations swirled around the warden’s simultaneous intimate relationships with three different female subordinates. Notably, each of these employees had received promotions, stirring speculations that their career advancements were tied to their intimate involvements.

The plaintiffs posited that such rampant favoritism, rooted in intimate relationships, painted a demeaning picture of the workplace. They contended that the warden’s behavior implicitly suggested that women were primarily seen as objects of sexual desire, and their professional ascent was tethered to their willingness to enter a romantic relationship with him.

What Was the Outcome?

The case initially met with skepticism in a lower California court. The court opined that since the aggrieved women weren’t directly propositioned or treated differently than their male colleagues, there was no ground for a sexual harassment claim.

However, this stance was upended by the California Supreme Court. In a pivotal decision, the higher court sided with the female employees. This asserted that workplace atmospheres tainted by sexual favoritism could indeed be grounds for a valid harassment claim.

What Is the Impact of This Case on California Law?

Historically, the occasional act of favoritism by a supervisor towards a subordinate with whom they share a consensual romantic relationship wouldn’t necessarily be viewed as sexual harassment under California law. However, the aftershocks of this case significantly recalibrated the legal perspective.

In light of this case, a supervisor indulging in multiple affairs with subordinates can potentially be seen as engendering a sexually harassing environment, encompassing even those who aren’t directly involved in any of the relationships.

This ruling underscores that one doesn’t have to be on the receiving end of unwanted advances or explicit requests for sexual favors to be considered a victim of sexual harassment. The broader implication for employers is clear: they could find themselves accountable for a manager’s pattern of sexual favoritism if it’s so pervasive that it crafts an environment where employees perceive romantic or sexual engagements as the de facto pathway to career progression.

This shifts the emphasis from individual interactions to the overall workplace atmosphere and its impact on employees’ perceptions and experiences.

How Can I File a Sexual Harassment Complaint?

If you are a victim of sexual harassment in the workplace, you have several options to file a complaint and seek remedies. Here are some steps you can take:

  • Inform your employer of the harassment, pursuant to the options and requirements set out in your employer’s sexual harassment policy, if such a policy exists. You should keep records of each incident of harassment, noting the date and time and any people involved.
  • File a complaint with the appropriate state or federal agency. You don’t need a lawyer to take this step. The California Civil Rights Department (CRD) is the state agency charged with protecting Californians from unlawful discrimination in employment. If there has been a violation of civil rights laws, CRD can pursue damages on your behalf. You may file a complaint with CRD online, by mail, or over the phone. The EEOC enforces federal anti-discrimination laws.
    • Their website has information on filing complaints. Complaints filed with CRD or EEOC are automatically cross-filed with the other agency. You only need to submit one complaint.
  • Obtain a right-to-sue letter from the CRD or EEOC after your complaint is evaluated. This letter will allow you to file a lawsuit against your employer for sexual harassment if you are not satisfied with the response from your employer or if you are not eligible for other remedies.

The Emotional and Psychological Impact of Sexual Harassment

Sexual harassment in the workplace isn’t just an organizational or legal concern; it deeply affects the lives of those who experience it. This form of misconduct goes beyond the immediate incident, leaving an indelible mark on victims’ emotional well-being, career prospects, and the overarching environment of a workplace.

1. Trauma and Stress

Sexual harassment is a traumatic event, and its repercussions mirror that of other traumatic experiences. Victims frequently report a myriad of emotional and psychological consequences:

  • Emotional Distress: The immediate aftermath can be characterized by feelings of vulnerability, shame, anger, confusion, and fear. Such emotions can be debilitating, interfering with the victim’s ability to function both professionally and personally.
  • Anxiety and Depression: Long after the incident, victims may grapple with heightened anxiety levels. They might fear a recurrence of the incident or become exceedingly wary of interactions with colleagues. Depression, characterized by feelings of hopelessness, sadness, and a decreased interest in previously enjoyed activities, can also be a consequence.
  • Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD): In severe cases, victims may show symptoms akin to PTSD. This can include reliving the traumatic incident through flashbacks, nightmares, and intrusive thoughts, actively avoiding reminders of the trauma, and heightened irritability or jumpiness.

2. Career Implications

The professional ramifications of sexual harassment are multi-faceted:

  • Avoidance Behavior: To sidestep potential harassment or the discomfort of interacting with the perpetrator, victims might decline important meetings, skip workplace events, or even forgo opportunities for promotion. This avoidance not only stifles their professional growth but can also lead to feelings of isolation.
  • Job Turnover: A significant number of harassment victims consider leaving their jobs to escape the hostile environment. Such decisions, though sometimes necessary for mental well-being, can disrupt a person’s career, leading to:
    • Potential financial instability;
    • The challenges of job-hunting: and
    • The loss of established professional networks.
  • Decreased Productivity: Constant anxiety and the emotional toll of harassment can impact a victim’s ability to focus on tasks, leading to reduced efficiency and productivity.

3. Company Culture

The ripple effect of sexual harassment permeates throughout an organization:

  • Morale Erosion: Even if employees aren’t directly affected by sexual harassment, witnessing or hearing about such incidents can result in feelings of unease and insecurity. This creates an atmosphere where trust in the organization’s values and leadership can quickly erode.
  • Lower Productivity: A hostile work environment isn’t conducive to optimal performance. Employees in such settings are less engaged, leading to lower overall productivity.
  • Higher Turnover Rates: Companies that fail to address and prevent sexual harassment might experience higher attrition rates. Replacing employees isn’t just costly; it can also lead to gaps in knowledge and skills within teams and departments.

In summary, the impact of sexual harassment stretches far beyond the immediate incident. Its consequences seep into the mental well-being of victims, shape their career choices, and influence the very fabric of an organization’s culture. Addressing such behavior promptly with the help of a California attorney isn’t just a legal or ethical necessity; it’s important for the holistic health of employees and the organization.

Should I Consult an Attorney About My Sexual Harassment Issue?

If you’ve experienced sexual harassment in the workplace, seek legal guidance. A California attorney who handles workplace harassment can offer the advice, direction, and representation you require. Your attorney will help you understand your rights, guide you through the complaint process, and ensure that you’re adequately represented if your case goes to court.

If you’re looking for guidance in this matter, consider connecting with a knowledgeable California sexual harassment lawyer through LegalMatch to fight for your cause and guide you through every step.

Law Library Disclaimer


16 people have successfully posted their cases

Find a Lawyer